Supreme Court forbids “Tzytramon-Zdorovie” production
The Supreme Court of Ukraine has approved the legal lawsuit of the PrJSC “Pharmaceutical firm “Darnitsa” (Kyiv) against the LLC “Pharmaceutical company “Zdorovie” ( Kharkiv) and forbade the Kharkiv based company to produce the medical agent “Tzytramon-Zdorovie”, said Aleksandr Mamunya, the partner of the AEQUO law firm, who represented “Darnitsa” interests in court.
“The court declared the state registration of the “Tsytramon-Zdorovie” invalid. This means it will be removed from the store shelves, prevented from selling in pharmacy chains, its production and export will be impossible,” the lawyer explained.
Although “Darnitsa” is the rightsholder on “Tsytramon” trademark, it doesn’t issue legal arguments with all the producers of this medical agent, Mamunya said.
“There’s a whole range of “Tsytramons” on the market. Some of them are harmless for “Darnitsa” business interests: they are being sold in certain regions, local pharmacies, the packaging is different from the medicine, produced by “Darnitsa,” he said.
According to the lawyer, “Tsytramon-Zdorovie” was, instead, on sale in the same places with Darnitsa's medical agent, and its packaging was repeating the white-green colored pack of the “Tsytramon-Darnitsa”.
“It was clearly an aggressive strategy aimed for using the counterpart's reputation as a steppingstone. Because “Darnitsa” has been investing in this product’s reputation for a long time – into the advertising, merchandising,” Mamunya said.
The lawyer is confident that this court decision creates an important precedent for Ukraine’s pharmaceuticals market.
“This case is unique - virtually the first precedent when the Health Ministry’s decision on medical agent registration was canceled on a base of trade and services mark. This is a signal to the foreign investors that in Ukraine the one can effectively protect intellectual property rights in court. Until today they didn’t believe such a method can work in Ukraine,” Mamunya explained.
“Tsytramon” – is an analgesic, anti-inflammatory medicine, produced in the form of pills. It has become an anti-headache medical agent of the year of the international festival-competition “The Choice of the Year 2018”.
PrJSC “Pharmaceutical firm “Darnitsa” was founded in 1930. The company is a leading producer of pharmaceuticals by volume in Ukraine. Company’s portfolio includes more than 250 names of medical products.
In 2018 “Darnitsa” increased its net profit by 31. 3 percent, to 449,134 million UAH.
The Zagoriy family, including the Verkhovna Rada lawmaker Glib Zagoriy, is the ultimate beneficiary of the company.
LLC “Pharmaceutical company “Zdorovie” was registered in 2001. According to the Justice Ministry data, Polish citizen Leonid Ogorodnikov is the ultimate beneficiary of the company.